Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

How To Choose a Great Local Real Estate Agent in New Jersey

Oriana Suarez September 1, 2024

Buyers

How To Choose a Great Local Real Estate Agent in New Jersey

Selecting the right real estate agent can make a world of difference when buying or selling a home. But how do you find the best one? Here are some tips to help you make that big decision as you determine your partner in the process.

Check Their Reputation

Start by gathering information about agents in your area. New Jersey boasts a wide range of communities, from bustling urban centers like Jersey City and Newark to serene suburbs like Westfield and Montclair. From there, try to narrow down the list by seeking recommendations from people you trust in your specific area. You’ll want to find an agent with a strong online presence, plenty of positive reviews, and someone whose great reputation truly precedes them.

For example, agents in highly competitive markets such as Hoboken often have numerous client testimonials and active social media profiles showcasing their successes. As Freddie Mac explains:

“. . . you may want to look for a real estate agent who specializes in the type of home you’re searching for. For example, if you are looking for an energy-efficient home, look for an agent who has experience with finding and negotiating offers for those homes. If you are looking for new construction, you’ll want to find an agent who has experience with new construction and isn’t affiliated with the builder . . .”

Look for Local Market Expertise

A great agent should have in-depth knowledge of what’s happening at both the national and local levels. In New Jersey, the real estate market can vary significantly from one township to another. For example, the market trends in affluent areas like Princeton differ greatly from those in more affordable regions like Trenton.

A local agent can clear up any misconceptions sparked by what you’re reading or hearing in the news. They can tell you how your specific area compares to national data. As a recent article from Business Insider says:

“Spend some time talking with prospective agents about the local real estate market and how it could impact your purchase or sale. You want to get an understanding of how knowledgeable they are about local market conditions. Whether they're helping you sell or buy, their strategy for you should account for those conditions.”

Get a Feel for Their Communication Style and Availability

Effective communication is key in real estate transactions. Choose an agent who listens to your needs, answers your questions quickly, and keeps you informed throughout the process. In New Jersey, where some areas have high transaction volumes, finding an agent who can give you personal attention is crucial.

If an agent is juggling too many clients, they might not be able to give you the attention you deserve. You want someone who will be readily available and responsive. So, what’s the best way to get a feel for their communication style and preferences? Bankrate offers this advice:

Interviews also give you a chance to find out the agent’s preferred method of communication and their availability. For example, if you’re most comfortable texting and expect to visit homes after work hours during the week, you’ll want an agent who’s happy to do the same.”

Trust Your Gut

Last, rely on your instincts. If you feel like you do or don’t click with one of the agents you’re talking to, that matters. Choose an agent you feel at ease with and who inspires confidence. The right agent should be someone you trust to guide you through one of the most significant transactions of your life. As Business Insider says:

“As long as you've properly vetted the agents you're considering and ensured they have the necessary expertise, it's ok to go with your gut . . . Maybe you have a better rapport with one of the agents you're considering, or you just feel like they're easier to approach. You're going to be working closely with this person, so it's important to choose an agent you're comfortable with.”

Bottom Line

By following these tips, you can pick an agent who’ll provide the support and expertise you need to help make the process as smooth as possible. In New Jersey’s unique market, having a knowledgeable and reliable agent is key to success. It’d be an honor to apply for that job. Let’s connect so we can have a conversation and see if we’d be a good fit for working together.

FREE consultation here!

(908) 445-5339 | [email protected]

Recent Blog Posts

Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.

Florostone Realty graphic titled 'Why More Homeowners Are Listing in Union County in 2025' set against a soft backdrop of downtown Union County, New Jersey.

Buyers

Is Union County, NJ a Good Place to Sell Your Home in 2025?

July 1, 2025

What today's market conditions, pricing trends, and buyer demand mean for Union County homeowners looking to sell.

Hero image for Florostone Realty’s 2025 affordability guide, titled “How Much House Can You Afford in Different NJ Counties,” with a suburban New Jersey neighborhood in the background.

Buyers

How Much House Can You Afford in Different NJ Counties in 2025?

June 24, 2025

2025 Home Affordability Guide Across Union, Middlesex, Essex, and Bergen Counties

Cover graphic for Florostone Realty’s article titled “Best NJ Towns for NYC Commuters – 2025 Guide for Buyers,” featuring a city skyline with New Jersey and New York postage stamp illustrations.

Tips

Best NJ Towns for NYC Commuters: 2025 Guide for Buyers

June 18, 2025

Featuring Union, Middlesex, Essex & Bergen Counties

Florostone Realty title graphic with skyline and benches, introducing a 2025 seller roadmap for Union County homeowners preparing to sell their property.

Sellers

Selling Your Home in Union County, NJ? A 2025 Seller’s Roadmap from Florostone Realty

June 11, 2025

Your step-by-step guide to selling a home in Union County, NJ—covering pricing, preparation, marketing, and closing in today’s 2025 real estate market.

Florostone Realty banner promoting first-time homebuyer programs in Roselle Park, NJ with aerial view of residential neighborhood. Text overlay reads 'First-Time Homebuyer Programs in Roselle Park, NJ (2025 Update)

Buyers

First-Time Homebuyer Programs in Roselle Park, NJ

June 4, 2025

Why Roselle Park Is a Great Choice for First-Time Buyers

Beige background with minimalist line art of a house in the background. Foreground text reads: “Where to Buy a Home in New Jersey: A County-by-County Guide.” Clean, modern design with soft tones and elegant typography.

Buyers

Where Should You Buy a Home in NJ? A Guide to Union, Middlesex, Essex, and Bergen Counties

May 21, 2025

Explore the top neighborhoods and housing markets in Union, Middlesex, Essex, and Bergen Counties with insights from the experts at Florostone Realty.

Florostone Realty graphic showcasing real estate marketing services, illustrating home staging, client interaction, and property sales with the tagline 'Want to see how our marketing makes homes shine?

Sellers

How to Sell Your Home Fast in Union, Middlesex, Essex, and Bergen Counties

May 13, 2025

Florostone Realty's Proven Strategies for Maximizing Home Sales in New Jersey's Competitive Markets

Florostone Realty graphic listing 5 key tips for selling a home in Union County, NJ, including pricing strategies, curb appeal, professional photography, optimal listing timing, and partnering with a local expert.

Tips

Selling a Home in Union County, NJ? 5 Key Tips for a Successful Sale

May 7, 2025

Expert Tips to Sell Fast and Maximize Value in 2025

Tips

How to Generate a Steady Stream of Buyer and Seller Leads Without Cold Calling

March 29, 2025

From SEO and social media to email marketing and referrals, this blog breaks down the best strategies to attract and convert leads without picking up the phone.

LET’S CONNECT

We strive to become your go-to Real Estate Advisors. Book a free consultation today and let’s get started with a buying or selling plan for your home customized to your unique timeline.